Rotolo's Pizzeria - Fairhope, AL

isaias R.

Worst experience I've had eating ANYWHERE! I asked for a drink that I've had here every Sunday for the past 6 months. They stated they've never heard of it. It's called a "White Russian"
Waited 30 minutes for the drink and still nobody had taken my order for food. Had to Google the drink for the bartender. I had to place the order with the lady that seated us. I asked for a pizza. Chicken wings and a Coke. They were out of chicken wings and Coke. I placed the order and ask for another drink. Got the order 40 minutes later, ate everything and got the drink I ordered after I finished.
Still can't comprehend why the server wouldn't tell us that they were backed up, apologized for the wait.
I guess my new Sunday spot will be the Ravenite! I'm so pissed off I left my glass of milk untouched. Is that really supposed to be a chocolate martini?

Amanda K.

My 8yr old son and I had lunch today and we LOVE this place. 1st of all the atmosphere was top knotch! Love the brickwork inside! We had a personal cheese pizza and the garlic bread bites! My son said "5 STARS MOM!" Jewels was our server and she was amazing!

There is TONS of seating in different areas. There are many big screen TVs showing sports and news. The back area is the arcade! For $5 we played air hockey, a driving game and the punch bag! My son had a blast! He visited the restroom before we left and told me it was very clean!

C F.

Just moved into town and saw this place. My daughter was excited it had an arcade so I thought it’d be a fun night for dinner and games. We were sat in the back at the arcade(daughter’s choice). The hostess was very lovely and brought our drinks but we never had a server check on us once for 30 minutes so we left. Very disappointing experience.

Rita P.

Food was very Fresh, if you want a crisp to your wings ask for them to be. Well done. Overall great food and cook. He personally brought our pizza out for us.

Edit: visit in Aug 7:30pm. Waited 15 mins before a waitress came to our table. Ordered chicken Alfredo. Seen in the 3rd pic. It was cold when brought to the table. asked for a new Alfredo and was brought the same dish that had been microwave. As seen in the 2nd pic. The chicken was so overcooked (1st pic) i just decided to just take it out. Overall experience. HORRIBLE. Would not recommend after lunch hours.

Belle

I don’t know what is wrong with this location. Seems to be no management involved, lots of loud noise, and lots of talking instead of tending to customers needs. The server if you wanna call it that, was terrible. She did the bare minimum and that was all. She brought us our food, and gave us receipts. Never came back to ask how the food was, or asked if we needed refills. Gave me the wrong salad dressing for my meal, so I HAD TO GET UP and ASK HER to get me the right damn dressing for my salad. In no circumstance necessary should a customer ever have to get up and ask the server something. Then when I was clearly standing there needing something, she had a AirPod in and was talking to a coworker before she assisted me. Wow, the priorities here. She was dressed in a pink hoodie and sweatpants, and I visited this location on 2/6/25. All the rest of the employees seemed to be in proper uniform, but this one lady. Completely unprofessional especially if you are coming to work. I don’t particularly care if this person is a manager, because if she is, that’s even worse on the company. Will not be returning to this location which is really sad because I do enjoy the food, but food can only get you so far. I can get better service at a gas station than I could here which is quite disappointing. If you can’t do your job good, then you need to find someone else who can.

Tawny K.

Came for lunch and jewels took care of me. She was phenomenal. I also met Nelson in the kitchen and he was so kind. He literally made my meal delightful! Between the 2 of them, my experience was 10/10!

Deianaria B.

This was my first time in there. The food didn’t have much flavor and didn’t expect it to come in such a small dish. There was no manager there. It took about 5 minutes for the server to come greet us. We ordered an appetizer they came out 2 minutes before our food. Our server only came by once or twice. We saw the bartender more than our server. Asked the bartender tender if she could get our check so we could go.

Garlic bites were good

Jim N.

I've eaten real Detroit pizza and this was not even pizza. The sauce was terrible. Pizza was raw. The tables and chairs were dirty. Definitely not going back.
Much better food in the area. Don't waste your money and time...