Amici Pizzeria - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Address: 2387 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716.
Phone: 328724333.
Website: amicipizzerianj.com
Specialties: Pizza restaurant.
Other points of interest: Curbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in, Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible seating, Comfort food, Private dining room, Quick bite, Vegan options, Vegetarian options, Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Dessert, Seating, Restroom, Casual, Cozy, Quiet, Family-friendly, Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Credit cards, Good for kids, High chairs, Free parking lot, Free street parking, On-site parking, Parking, Dogs allowed outside.
Opinions: This company has 140 reviews on Google My Business.
Average opinion: 4.6/5.

📌 Location of Amici Pizzeria

Amici Pizzeria 2387 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716

☎️328724333

⏰ Open Hours of Amici Pizzeria

Monday: 12–9 PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 12–9 PM
Thursday: 12–9 PM
Friday: 12–10 PM
Saturday: 12–10 PM
Sunday: 12–8 PM

Overview of Amici Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Atlantic Highlands, NJ, at

2387 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716

, stands Amici Pizzeria, a beloved local institution renowned for its exceptional pizza and cozy atmosphere. With a convenient phone number , customers can easily reach out for any inquiries or to place an order. The pizzeria's online presence is equally welcoming, as you can explore their menu and place orders through their website amicipizzerianj.com.

Key Features and Services

Specialties: Amici Pizzeria specializes in delivering top-notch pizzas, but their menu extends far beyond their signature pies. They cater to a wide range of preferences with Vegan options, Vegetarian options, and a variety of Pizzas, including those perfect for Lunch, Dinner, and even Takeout.

Customers can enjoy their meal in several ways:

Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
On-site Dine-in
Takeout
Private dining room for special occasions

Accessibility and Comfort: The pizzeria is wheelchair accessible, ensuring all patrons can enjoy the comfortable parking lot, seating, and facilities. They cater to families with high chairs and a free parking lot. Pets are welcome outside, making it a great spot for a family outing.

Dining Experience

Reservations aren't necessary for a casual dining experience, but for larger groups, the private dining room is available. Amici Pizzeria prides itself on being family-friendly, offering a warm and cozy environment that's perfect for all ages. The menu includes comfort food favorites, and they accept various payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and even NFC mobile payments.

Reviews and Popularity

Amici Pizzeria shines brightly in customer reviews, boasting an impressive average rating of 4.6/5 based on 140 reviews on Google My Business. Patrons rave about the amazing pizza, fresh ingredients, and the welcoming atmosphere. Many visitors, like those who spoke favorably about trying the New Jersey Devils pie, have expressed their eagerness to return. The pizzeria's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident from the overwhelmingly positive feedback.

Additional Information

For those looking to visit, it's worth noting that Amici Pizzeria offers a variety of dining options, from quick bites to full meals. Whether you're solo dining or planning a family outing, there's something for everyone. The pizzeria's convenient location at the free street parking area, combined with its own parking, makes it easily accessible. For those seeking a quiet, cozy spot to enjoy comfort food, Amici Pizzeria is highly recommended.

👍 Reviews of Amici Pizzeria

Amici Pizzeria - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Stevenson A.

5/5

Amazing pizza, We have gotten multiple pies and all have been great. The veggie ones are full of freshly cut veggies, we have 2 vegan friends and they love Amici. Today I got a grilled chicken garden salad with oil and vinegar. Nothing here disappoints. Highly recommended.

The N. S.

5/5

I got to know the owners through interviewing one of them through my New Jersey Devils podcast. I went in with a friend to try the New Jersey Devils pie and it was fantastic! It looked super cool, the sauce was great and pie overall was tremendous! Loved getting to know the people there and I'm excited to come back asap!

Ivy C.

5/5

The cutest little restaurant where you are welcome with a warm greeting and a smile, really making it feel like home!

All the sauces are scratch made, and you can really tell, the vodka sauce is my favorite! It’s fantastic on this gigantic garlic slider that they make, with real garlic butter none of that fake stuff! And the vodka sauce? Out of this world!

You can get slices but getting a whole pie is the way to go! And if you want a more elevated experience, they have a dining room complete with artwork and lighting. And if you want a cute appetizer to start get the fried gnocchi!

Cosme Q. Q.

1/5

Terrible service, in this place they don't know how to make food, this is the second time I've been through this, to make a chiken caesar wrap it took half an hour, the wrap it was all lettuce, the guy told me they only had whole wead tortilla , and he gave me another type of tortilla, the wrap came with some prepackaged potatoes, be sure to check the review of the place before placing your orders...👎👎👎

Lindsey A.

5/5

I got a chance to sample a slice of their white pizza at the Jersey Eats NJ Pizza Festival. The slice was the first one I had and yet it is still one of the most memorable for me. The crust was crispy yet soft and unbelievable - no flop! The pizza was savory and had the perfect dollops of ricotta. The cheese wasn't slopping off, everything stayed together nicely. It even had a unique crust that had "everything but the bagel" seasoning encrusted on top. I normally don't go for a white pizza but seeing this at first glance I just felt gravitated to try it and I'm glad I did! This is a great family operated pizzeria. The family is super kind and proud of their business which I took away in the few moments I interacted with them at the festival. I wish them all the best and hope to stop by for some more of their pizza if I'm ever in the area! I recommend you try them!

Charles L.

5/5

My son just said it was the best chicken francaise ever and the grilled chicken was delicious and a great amount after the gym!! Highly recommend supporting !!!

Anna G.

5/5

The day I found Amici’s pizza was the day all other pizzas died cause no one makes pizza like Amicis it has the best taste!!! The antipasto salad is the best the meatballs are the best tasting I moved from living close to them but I still drive to get Amici’s I will not settle for any pizza it has to be Amicis
I think you should try it I’m sure you’ll love them I always order a med.pepperoni pizza antipasto salad and side of meatballs I’m in heaven for the night thank you AMICIS!!

Dillon L.

5/5

Ordered takeout over the phone on a Sunday afternoon around 4:45pm. Quick and easy. When I picked up, order was all correct.
(Large margherita pie. Large buffalo wings with Bleu cheese. Penne vodka with chicken)

Easy drive to get here (right off route 36)
Plenty of parking spots. They are a part of a small strip mall that includes a sushi spot, gym, dollar store, nail salon etc so parking is never an issue.

Wings were the crispy and just the right amount of sauce. Pizza was perfect, melty cheese with the thin crust that was in between soft and firm.
Pasta was huge.. it was packed full with chicken. Needed a little salt though.

Hands down the best pizza for the price around the area.
They also have a loyalty program. Just add your phone number and after you spend $100, you'll get 10% off your next order.