Casa Maya Mexican Grill - Shell Knob, Missouri

Casa Maya Mexican Grill: A Local Gem in Shell Knob, Missouri

Casa Maya Mexican Grill is a popular dining establishment located in the heart of Shell Knob, Missouri. Situated at 25392 State Hwy 39, this restaurant offers a casual and inviting atmosphere for those seeking authentic Mexican cuisine. With a dedicated phone line at 4178580500 and a user-friendly website at casamayamexicangrillmo.com, Casa Maya provides convenient options for customers to learn more and place orders.

### Specialities and Menu Offerings

Casa Maya Mexican Grill specializes in delivering a diverse range of Mexican dishes. While the specific menu may vary, patrons can generally expect to find classic favorites such as tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and quesadillas. The restaurant’s focus is on providing satisfying and flavorful meals that cater to a broad range of tastes. It’s evident, based on customer feedback, that a significant portion of their appeal lies in their creative and unique offerings, particularly concerning their signature drinks.

### Dining Options and Services

Casa Maya offers a variety of ways for guests to enjoy their meals. Customers can choose to dine-in, providing a traditional restaurant experience. Alternatively, they can opt for takeaway for convenient meals to enjoy at home. For those seeking a quick and easy option, kerbside pickup is available. Furthermore, the restaurant provides delivery services, expanding their reach to customers within the surrounding area. A drive-through is also an available option, streamlining the ordering process for busy patrons. The commitment to offering multiple service methods demonstrates a customer-centric approach, acknowledging the diverse preferences of the local community.

### Customer Feedback and Reputation

Casa Maya Mexican Grill currently boasts 10 reviews on Google My Business, offering a snapshot of customer experiences. The average opinion is 3.1/5, suggesting there is room for improvement in certain areas while also highlighting strengths in others. While the overall rating indicates a mixed experience, several comments suggest that the food itself is a significant draw, particularly given the restaurant's location. Notably, several reviewers have praised the restaurant’s unique offerings, specifically mentioning the “Red Bull blackberry margaritas.” This unconventional drink combination has garnered considerable attention and appears to be a standout item on the menu.

### Key Observations and Potential Areas for Development

The reviews suggest that the food quality is inconsistent – some customers describe it as ‘so-so’ and noting instances of ‘runniness’ and ‘blandness,’ particularly regarding Tex-Mex dishes. However, the overwhelmingly positive feedback on the margaritas indicates a successful culinary innovation. Service is described as ‘OK but not great,’ suggesting an opportunity for staff training to enhance the overall customer experience. There are also mentions of margaritas being ‘weak’ and the margarita tower being of interest, though not necessarily tried. It’s apparent that the restaurant’s primary appeal currently stems from its location and its ability to offer a unique alternative in a relatively isolated area.

### Contact Information and Website

For more detailed information about Casa Maya Mexican Grill, including the most up-to-date menu and operating hours, we encourage visitors to explore their website at casamayamexicangrillmo.com. Alternatively, you can reach them directly by phone at 4178580500. The restaurant's address is 25392 State Hwy 39, Shell Knob, MO 65747.

Food is a central component of their offerings, and they strive to provide a palatable experience for their patrons.

👍 Reviews of Casa Maya Mexican Grill

Joey E.

5/5

Amazing food for being in the middle of nowhere! Great staff and don't get me started on the Red Bull blackberry margaritas! I never had a red bull margarita and never thought to mix red bull with tequila and I'm sold! Best drink hands down

Jim N.

3/5

Only place around. Service is OK but not great. Food so-so. Tends to be runny and bland for TexMax. Frozen Margaritas are weak. Margaritas tower is interesting but we did not try it.

JR M.

5/5

Food was really good if you're Hispanic, not a bad place. I got the mocajete, and it was super good, really nice seasoned food. Tortillas are good. I wish they were fresh but other than that.Not a bad tex mex place

Linda R.

1/5

years ago it was just average. Today, June 6, 2025 the same average. the menu was nice looking but you couldn't read the details of a dish or price because it was so tiny print. The drinks (pop) was $6.00 for 2 drinks, the large guacamole was over $11.00 and started to turn black as we sat there. The meal was $56.00 for 2 $11.00 dishes and 1 to go dish of $12.00. The waitress was very good. Just check the prices before you order.
We will not ever go back there.

David H.

1/5

Don't go too slow. Was ignored the minute we walked in the door. New ownership needs help.

Ninja K.

1/5

We went out to eat here on a Friday night. (Yes it's busy) we was okay waiting for a table to be seated about 15mins.
We ordered as soon as we sat down food drinks and all we was ready!
1 hour passed!!!!! (Its sooooo hot in there as well i dont think the air is working!)
Man comes to table asked us if we have had r food. We replied kindly No.
He ask us what we had and he comes back few mins later with food.
Something I did not order at all. At this point we tell the waiter that it's not what I wanted and I even showed the waitress on the menu what I did want in the beginning. As soon as I said "this is not what I ordered" the waiter said "well u said!!!!!!" Ummmmm excuses me!!!!!
they forgot us forgot r order we waited n hour for him to blame me not cool!!!!
This is the third let down we have had here. And we gave it another try. We will not be returning and we will let everyone know about the experience they may have.

Sandra D.

1/5

Called in order. Person never took my name and could tell he was not writing order down. Mu order was missing a entire entree Never again!

Jason W.

5/5

Amazing food, and have been killing it for years now!