Hightstown Hot Bagels - Hightstown, New Jersey

George R.

Super cool little shop serving some serious bagels. God, I wish we had some of these authentic homemade bagels down in SC. I had a toasted bagel with cream cheese. My wife had a toasted Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich. Both were incredible. Very friendly staff.

Ahmed I.

Absolutely love this place! The bagels are always fresh, with the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Their cream cheese is amazing, and the sandwiches are packed with flavor. It’s my favorite spot for breakfast or whenever I’m craving a good bagel. Highly recommend!

Khairy K.

"Hightstown Hot Bagel is a gem! Freshly baked, generous portions, and unbeatable prices. Try the Classic Everything Bagel with scallion cream cheese - absolute perfection!"

Quinn L.

Little Hot Bagel shop right in downtown Highstown that I love to stop by every now and then to grab a quick, hot, and delicious bagels. I got everything bagel with Nova Lox and cream cheese. Very fulfilling and tasty! I used to get one hot from the grill which had sausage, egg, and cheese on everything bagel as well. It came out hot and fresh, went so well with a cup of coffee.

There’re plenty parking spaces in front of the shop as well. Reasonable prices with fast and friendly service. Definitely recommend if you’re in town and will come back.

kuang H.

Over all it wasn’t bad and the price was reasonable, had everything bagel with egg and sausage. However the sausage taste like almost Indian curry flavored but I like it. Would I come back yes. The only thing I didn’t like was there were no table for eat in bits it’s ok and that’s why I put atmosphere two stars

lana A.

Saw the one star review about them running out of bagels and ran out of the house to go try their bagels because that’s a positive review to me!! Bagels are so fresh and the cream cheese tastes so fresh! Will definitely be going back!

Salma I.

I've tried so many bagel shops in all of Jersey and NYC, and this is hands down my favorite bagel shop ever! The quality can't get better than this, and the service has never failed. I'm always excited to get my bagel in the morning thanks to Hightstown Hot Bagels. My usual order is a toasted everything bagel with veggie cream cheese and lox/tomatoes (highly recommend!) and they get it right EVERY single time. If you're in Jersey and haven't tried this place out you're missing out; it's amazing! (:

Amal E.

This business has been serving the community for 30 years, and no low-quality establishment lasts that long. Any small business has the right to operate as they see fit, as long as they adhere to health guidelines. Whether or not they choose to serve pork is entirely their decision, just as it is your choice to seek out another place that offers it. When I purchase halal, kosher, or pork products, I respect both my choice and the choices of the businesses I support.
This family-run business has built a strong reputation over the years, and a few negative reviews cannot overshadow the beauty of the town and the loyal support of its residents. Known for its top-quality bagels, cream cheese, and exceptional service, this shop has become a beloved staple in the community. The staff is consistently friendly and respectful, and their dedication to excellence speaks for itself.