Mikey's Meats - Matawan, New Jersey

Mark L.

Went there today to pickup some exotic meats.
Friendly butcher and owner and fairly price meats. Purchased Waygu Beef, Venison parts for stew and chicken hearts. Looking forward to cooking and eating!

Maxim K.

Improved Review:
Impressive Selection and Stellar Service
This small shop packs a big punch with its impressive selection of products. The owner's friendly and knowledgeable demeanor made our visit even more enjoyable. We were intrigued by their dinosaur ribs and decided to give them a try. We were not disappointed! The ribs were absolutely fantastic. We'll definitely be returning customers.

Hannah P.

My husband and I have been shopping at Mikey’s Meats almost every week, and we couldn’t be happier with our experiences. Not once have we brought home a piece of meat that wasn’t top-notch in quality. Some of our favorites include the NY strip steaks, T-bone steaks, bbq steak skewers, pork ribs, and wagyu burgers. Oh, and our dogs LOVE their bones too! It’s a win-win for the entire family! The store is beautiful and clean with plenty of parking, and the prices are incredibly reasonable, especially considering the superior freshness and taste compared to what you’d find at a commercial retail store.

What truly sets this place apart is Mikey and his staff — they are so personable and always willing to chat or offer recommendations. It’s clear they care about their customers and their craft. We’re so fortunate to have this shop in our community, and after experiencing the difference, we can’t imagine going back to buying meat anywhere else! We HIGHLY recommend you check out Mikey’s Meats ASAP!

Brian M.

Mikey's meats is the best butcher i ever been to. Huge selection!!! Always fresh and excellent taste! Them cooking on their video looks so good. The bonus part about going to the shop or watching their videos online, is the entertainment you get! I swear I wanna put a couch in the shop and just watch them all day. Very friendly and funny atmosphere! The town needed this place in a big way!

Reggie G.

Mikey’s Meats is a cut above the rest when it comes to top-quality meats and exceptional service. Their prime cuts are second to none, with the beef ribeye steak delivering rich marbling and bold flavor, the fresh Italian sausage packed with just the right balance of seasoning, and the succulent pork chops offering incredible tenderness. Every selection reflects their commitment to quality. The customer service is just as impressive, knowledgeable, friendly, and always ready to help you find exactly what you need. If you’re looking for premium meats and a great shopping experience, Mikey’s Meats is the place to go.

David B.

I recently picked up some beef braciole, pork braciole, meatballs, sweet Italian sausage, and pork neckbones from Mikey’s Meat Market to make our Sunday sauce. It was a huge hit! The quality of the meat was impeccable—everything tasted so fresh and flavorful, making our sauce rich, savory, and truly unforgettable.

The braciole, meatballs and Italian sausage added the perfect blend of spices, while the pork neckbones gave the sauce incredible depth and body. We could tell that Mikey’s takes pride in their products, and it shows in every bite. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about what they do, helping me pick the best ingredients for our recipe. (shoutout to Jay for his help!)

We’ll definitely be coming back for more, and I’d highly recommend Mikey’s to anyone looking for top-notch meats. This place is a gem in Matawan, and if you’re serious about cooking, you’ve got to give them a try. Thank you, Mikey’s, for taking our Sunday sauce to the next level!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Highly recommended!

Peter M.

This place is great. Every time I go in there I ask a lot of questions about different types of meat to help me decide what to get and the butcher is always patient and knowledgeable about everything. The meat is fresh and they have a great selection of high quality meats that you can’t find at a typical grocery store. I highly recommend checking this place out!

Jessica K.

As a first time customer I was shocked at how much the staff bent over backwards for me. I called asking if they had a certain meat in stock, they said yes, I told them how I would like it prepared and asked if being there within an hour for pick up works and they said yes. The inside smells so good and it is so cool to see all of the exotic meats they have to offer. Of course you're spending a little more than a typical food store but the meat was to die for. Very happy customer.