Peter's Fish Market - Midland Park, New Jersey

Peter's Fish Market

Located at 190 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, Peter's Fish Market is a popular seafood market that offers a wide variety of fresh seafood and other seafood-related products.

With a strong focus on customer satisfaction, Peter's Fish Market has gained a loyal following among locals and visitors alike.

Specialties

Seafood market is the specialty of Peter's Fish Market, offering a wide range of fresh seafood, including fish, shellfish, and other seafood delicacies.

The market also offers a variety of seafood-related products, such as seafood sauces, marinades, and cooking supplies.

Other points of interest

Peter's Fish Market is a small business that is committed to providing excellent customer service and ensuring that all customers have a positive experience.

The market is also wheelchair accessible, making it easy for customers with mobility issues to navigate and shop.

Additionally, the market offers delivery services, making it convenient for customers who prefer to have their seafood delivered to their doorstep.

Reviews and ratings

This company has 285 reviews on Google My Business, with an average rating of 4.5/5.

Overall, Peter's Fish Market is a highly-rated and reputable seafood market that is well worth visiting.

Key information

Address: 190 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432

Phone: 201-444-3331

Website: petersfishmarket.com

Hours of operation: Not specified

👍 Reviews of Peter's Fish Market

VIP S. L.

1/5

The bold man behind the counter needs urgent customer service training. He says cash or check. Then he says ATM is right there. Go get cash. Horrible! I don’t know if the fish is fresh or not yet, but I’m not coming back here. Also, IRS should go over their receipts. He did not give me a cash receipt.

nicole F.

5/5

Love this place. Always come here when I wanna treat myself to absolutely delicious fish even though I live half an hour away the guys working there are so fast and friendly, I always get the salmon and tuna but also love the scallops (I made crudo with them and they are amazing) as well as the shrimp with cocktail sauce. Amazing. I wish I owned it!

zach -.

3/5

Fish is always fresh, order was missing baby octopus. Would have been fine if notified prior to getting the order, so we could plan accordingly. Unfortunately lost a reoccurring customer.

Marilyn G.

5/5

First class Best fish market. Always fresh, always clean. The new store is beautiful and has some great products..Highly recommend.

Linda

2/5

Excellent fish; terrible customer service. I have bought fish from Peter's for many years and it was always excellent. Then I bought 3 cooked, 1 1/2 lb lobsters which cost just over $110.00. One was excellent, two were spoiled and inedible, dangerously so. They offered to give me a refund for the spoiled ones, then gave me $20.00. When I protested I was told, with a sneer, "that's what you get". They lost a good customer.

Gerald C.

5/5

Awesome fresh fish. Quick service and good selection. Yeah there are some caveats like cash only and they do start putting stuff away about half an hour before closing. So what? I’d rather support a local small business by paying cash. And lots of places start to close up early. Prices seem reasonable. I would prefer Pete’s fish any day to some other stinky fish market.

Linda K.

5/5

Freshest seafood in Northern NJ. Staff is friendly and super helpful! Have been coming here for years.

Ruth A.

5/5

Peter's is a great fish market. It has it's own parking lot. The store is always so clean. The fish is as fresh as can be. The selection is large. I've never regretted buying fish there.